ops: continue queue-health evidence after #712 comment-cap exhaustion

Why this successor exists

Issue #712 remains the canonical historical RCA/evidence owner for organization-wide GitHub Actions queue starvation, but GitHub now rejects new comments on it with HTTP 403: Commenting is disabled on issues with more than 2500 comments. Do not close #712 or discard its evidence. This issue is a bounded continuation surface for new exact-head queue-health specimens and owner actions once #712's discussion channel is no longer writable.

The predecessor acceptance contract remains authoritative: distinguish source head → run/check materialization → runner admission → executed steps → terminal conclusion; identify current versus obsolete work; preserve the sole current-head evidence; cancel only provably obsolete work; surface queue age/runner assignment and explicit external/manual blockers; keep unavailable runners fail-closed rather than treating them as success.

Fresh continuation specimen — quarantine-sandbox-runtime

ContextualWisdomLab/quarantine-sandbox-runtime#144 exact head a5f4827c45d29ce50d617a08892ad82cba0c0018, CI run 35893629845:

verify 107291995573 — [ubuntu-24.04], queued since 2026-09-23T17:09:04Z, runner_id=0, empty runner identity, steps=[];
coverage 107291995966 — same hosted pre-runner state;
branch-coverage 107291996110 — same hosted pre-runner state;
podman-e2e-negative-rootless-apparmor 107291996362 — same hosted pre-runner state;
podman-e2e-positive-lsm 107291995951 — [self-hosted, linux, cwl-hostile-workload, selinux], also queued with runner_id=0 and steps=[].

#144 is the sole current exact test/doctoring head for the pre-admission destructive-authority RED: a creation-event-selected candidate_network_id is an inspection selector only until full P0 admission; no network rm is permitted before promotion. Moving, blind-rerunning, or no-op waking this exact would destroy the intended causal observation.

Fresh workflow-level reads also show QSR #127 b81468346a88c37ed920f6417571b9e7cc846b4d / 35865329024, #143 6f2e502a156a0d638b8c5ef55b546b4e041d5510 / 35872638890, and #102 e1be8a36654eab97617b3230de4595b05717143e / 35873273661 still queued. This is evidence that both ordinary hosted and dedicated self-hosted lanes remain incomplete; it is not by itself proof of a single shared root cause.

Continuation rules

Preserve ops: diagnose and bound organization GitHub Actions queue starvation #712 and link back to it for historical evidence; do not duplicate or rewrite its 2500-comment history.
New specimens here must record exact repository/PR/head/run/job/labels/creation time/queue age/runner identity/step materialization and current-vs-obsolete classification.
No leaf no-op commit, blind rerun, runner-selector weakening, timeout inflation, gate bypass, or predecessor-status transfer to manufacture activity.
If a queued exact later acquires a runner without source churn, record that same-head transition as control evidence.
If billing, organization policy, GitHub-hosted capacity, self-hosted capacity, environment approval, or another external prerequisite is the blocker, identify it explicitly rather than turning absence of execution into a source finding.

Completion

This continuation is complete only when #712's acceptance is demonstrably succeeded by a durable machine-readable health/reporting path and the organization can classify current-head queue state without relying on an unwritable mega-thread. Until then, #712 + this continuation jointly remain owner evidence; neither should be closed merely because a newer specimen exists.

Refs #712 #1531

Fresh current-head queue specimen — ContextualWisdomLab/quarantine-sandbox-runtime#145 exact 2eea75b4f40faf3c95e7d3e8484525e51a845f25, CI 35920385591.

All five jobs were freshly read on the same unchanged head and remain pre-runner queued since 2026-09-23T21:06:55Z:

branch-coverage 107382539541 — [ubuntu-24.04], runner_id=0, empty runner identity, steps=[];
podman-e2e-negative-rootless-apparmor 107382539751 — [ubuntu-24.04], same state;
coverage 107382539882 — [ubuntu-24.04], same state;
verify 107382539985 — [ubuntu-24.04], same state;
podman-e2e-positive-lsm 107382539902 — [self-hosted, linux, cwl-hostile-workload, selinux], runner_id=0, empty runner identity, steps=[].

#145 is the current test/TRACEABILITY-only successful-lease network-authority witness above canonical #127. Its exact must remain unchanged to observe whether the existing implementation reaches the intended public-correlation/private-destructive-authority RED. Do not blind-rerun, cancel/recreate, no-op wake, weaken labels, inflate timeouts, or transfer predecessor status.

This is a later QSR specimen than the #144 record in the issue body and shows both GitHub-hosted and dedicated self-hosted lanes still waiting before step materialization. It strengthens the queue-health evidence set but does not by itself prove one shared root cause across runner classes.

Fresh Wardnet queue-health specimen from the current gateway hardening lane. These are unchanged current heads after ordinary forward-only fixture corrections/restacks, not no-op wake commits.

ContextualWisdomLab/wardnet#446 exact b8b5804b655a424967252d8ac22172eb4a1338fb: CI run 35918347719, rust job 107375610618, status queued, conclusion null, no executed steps. This child is test-only; predecessor execution already separated a redirect-confounded 302 witness from the current 201 duplicate-Location witness.
wardnet#448 exact 8a254028faf4db0485ba8710945c2781a876fbed: CI 35917178809 remains queued, conclusion null; the head only contains the rustfmt-prescribed fixture reflow, so the intended Content-Encoding semantic RED is still incomplete until a runner actually reaches the test.
wardnet#443 exact 2cccfb37b85c3fc30d4b91d3027266feaf338774: CI 35921459298 and its current required lanes remain incomplete evidence for the added slow-consumer/concurrent streaming witnesses. Earlier hosted runs established the underlying whole-response-buffering RED, but predecessor results are not being promoted to this current head.

Leaf acceptance remains fail-closed: preserve these current heads, acquire runner(s), execute to terminal deterministic/security results, and cancel only provably obsolete predecessors. No blind rerun, runner-selector weakening, timeout inflation, synthetic status, gate weakening, or wake churn in Wardnet.

Queue RCA narrowing for the unchanged QSR #145 specimen 2eea75b4f40faf3c95e7d3e8484525e51a845f25 / 35920385591.

Fresh read still shows all five jobs pre-runner queued: hosted branch-coverage 107382539541, negative rootless/AppArmor 107382539751, coverage 107382539882, and verify 107382539985 are [ubuntu-24.04] with runner_id=0 and steps=[]; positive LSM 107382539902 is [self-hosted, linux, cwl-hostile-workload, selinux] with the same no-runner/no-step state. The run was created at 2026-09-23T21:06:54Z, so the current observation is a same-head queue transition with no source churn.

Public GitHub Status currently reports Actions Operational, and its Sep 23 history reports No incidents reported. The most recent Actions start-delay incident shown in public history is Sep 14 and was limited to some larger-runner jobs; the Sep 20 incident concerned Pull Requests. Therefore the present QSR starvation is not supported by public status evidence as a contemporaneous platform-wide Actions incident. This does not identify the positive cause: repository/org policy, account/billing state, GitHub-hosted admission/capacity not reflected on public status, and the dedicated self-hosted runner's registration/online/busy/label state remain separate hypotheses that require direct owner-visible evidence.

Preserve the exact heads. Do not blind-rerun, no-op wake, cancel/recreate, weaken labels, or transfer predecessor status. The next useful RCA evidence is direct runner/admission/account-policy state, not another leaf-source mutation.

Public status authority: https://www.githubstatus.com/

Additional QSR RCA narrowing from the exact #145 workflow definition (2eea75b4f40faf3c95e7d3e8484525e51a845f25).

.github/workflows/ci.yml uses:

concurrency:
  group: ${{ github.workflow }}-${{ github.repository }}-${{ github.event_name == 'pull_request' && github.event.pull_request.number || github.run_id }}
  cancel-in-progress: true

For pull requests, the concurrency key therefore includes the PR number. #145 cannot be serialized behind #127/#144/#143/#102 merely because they share the same CI workflow; they occupy distinct concurrency groups. Within #145, a newer run would cancel the older in-progress member rather than intentionally queue behind it. The current exact also has only the current commit run 35920385591 in the fresh commit-level read.

So two candidate explanations are now unsupported by direct evidence: (1) a contemporaneous publicly reported GitHub Actions incident, and (2) cross-PR workflow-concurrency serialization. Continue RCA at runner/account/admission state: hosted-job entitlement/billing/policy/admission and the self-hosted cwl-hostile-workload + selinux runner registration/online/busy/label state. Preserve current leaf heads while acquiring that evidence.

ConceptWeave continuation specimen — fresh read 2026-09-24 ~00:42 UTC.

Product ruleset owner evidence, current and irreplaceable

target owner: fix(governance): stage ConceptWeave Product ruleset enforcement #2350
exact head: a1af52d7bf2fcb5dfd27790961faf62651b16510
workflow/run: ConceptWeave Product Ruleset Reconcile / 35918073452, pull_request attempt 1
job: validate / 107374677579
labels: [ubuntu-24.04]
created: 2026-09-23T20:45:27Z
fresh state: queued, runner_id=0, empty runner/group identity, steps=[], no terminal conclusion; ~3h57m pre-runner queue age at this read
classification: CURRENT. This is the exact test-only coverage successor whose terminal owner evidence is required before separate review 5294002721 may stage the post-blob protected-ref RED. Do not cancel, blind-rerun, no-op wake, or move fix(governance): stage ConceptWeave Product ruleset enforcement #2350 merely to manufacture a new generation.

ConceptWeave#35 downstream CodeQL settlement, current queue specimen

target tuple: ContextualWisdomLab/ConceptWeave#35@d7b7e30b278ec2f27096b4d313c7d5eaf5387ddc / base f4f440dd58c77d7cd90dff8a1eb2eeb9a9940425 / required run 35825042996
downstream .github run: 35870670165
settlement job: settle exact required run / 107396154783
labels: [ubuntu-24.04]
created: 2026-09-23T21:46:26Z
fresh state: queued, runner_id=0, empty runner/group identity, steps=[]; ~2h56m pre-runner queue age at this read
classification: CURRENT downstream settlement for the unchanged 🛡️ Sentinel: [HIGH] Fix HTML Comment Breakout in JSON Serialization #35 tuple.

Important control: the same downstream run already obtained runners for both language scans. Python 107322443235 and Actions 107322443261 are terminal FAILURE only at Verify GHAS base/head CodeQL configuration identity, after exact-head materialization, CodeQL analysis and the Medium+ SARIF gate all succeeded; evidence preservation/status publication also succeeded. Those are central GHAS identity/credential findings (#1929/#2275/#2276), not queue specimens and not ConceptWeave source defects. validate-dispatch 107213600319 is terminal SUCCESS.

This therefore gives two current runnerless hosted [ubuntu-24.04] jobs in distinct owner workflows while also showing that nearby jobs can eventually acquire hosted runners. It is evidence of unresolved admission/queue behavior, not proof of one root cause. Preserve both exact heads and record any same-head transition to runner assignment as control evidence.

Wardnet current-head queue specimen (2026-09-24): ContextualWisdomLab/wardnet#448 exact head 30b52cae32b7022237c552aa6224ebd7d9dfb632, CI run 35941616793, job 107450501753 (rust, label [ubuntu-24.04]). Created/started 2026-09-24T01:08:38Z; fresh read remains queued, runner_id=0, empty runner/group identity, steps=[]. Classification: this is the sole current-head semantic GREEN gate for Wardnet issue #447 / PR #448 (hostile real-loopback Content-Encoding regression lane); it is current, not obsolete, and must not be cancelled, blind-rerun, bypassed, or replaced by predecessor evidence. No root cause beyond pre-runner non-assignment is inferred from this specimen. Acceptance for this consumer: unchanged exact head acquires a runner and run 35941616793 reaches a terminal conclusion; only terminal success permits #448 integration into parent #441.

ConceptWeave Product queue succession update: prior specimen .github#2350@a1af52d7bf2fcb5dfd27790961faf62651b16510 / run 35918073452 is now obsolete as a queue specimen because it completed SUCCESS. The current exact specimen is #2350 1a6ddce2d02df50dddeb81450ff05cb9778c94a9 / Product Ruleset Reconcile 35944402217 / validate 107459043420; fresh reads show the job still queued before runner assignment with no steps. This is a substantive test-only RED head for review 5294002721, not a wake commit, so preserve it unchanged and do not blind-rerun. Separate #35 CodeQL settlement 107396154783 remains the current runnerless queue specimen; its Python/Actions language shards already received runners and failed only at GHAS configuration-identity verification, so they are not queue specimens.

Fresh same-head transition narrows the QSR queue diagnosis. quarantine-sandbox-runtime#145 exact 2eea75b4f40faf3c95e7d3e8484525e51a845f25, CI 35920385591, is no longer a hosted pre-runner specimen: hosted branch-coverage 107382539541, negative rootless/AppArmor 107382539751, coverage 107382539882, and verify 107382539985 all acquired runners and executed without source churn. Negative rootless/AppArmor completed GREEN; verify/coverage/branch-coverage reached repository work and failed for source/test reasons. Only positive SELinux 107382539902 remains [self-hosted, linux, cwl-hostile-workload, selinux], queued with runner_id=0 and no steps.

This falsifies the previous broad interpretation for this exact: GitHub-hosted admission is functioning again, while the dedicated positive-SELinux lane remains unassigned. Do not transfer the earlier hosted queue state onto the executed jobs and do not blind-rerun them.

Current owner follow-up also created #127 temporary bounded source-fix head 998235f5351c58a4bfc0d80dfceb16c751c74406; its dedicated push repair run 35947287632, job 107467966641, is presently queued on ubuntu-24.04. That run is current work, not a reason to weaken gates. Preserve it until runner admission or a newer exact supersedes it.

Queue-health continuation update: the earlier hosted-runner starvation is no longer current for QSR, while the dedicated SELinux lane is still blocked.

QSR #144 exact a5f4827c45d29ce50d617a08892ad82cba0c0018 / 35893629845 acquired hosted runners on 2026-09-23 20:47Z: verify/coverage/branch-coverage executed, hosted rootless/AppArmor negative completed GREEN, and coverage reproduced the intended four-case pre-admission security RED. Its positive [self-hosted, linux, cwl-hostile-workload, selinux] job 107291995951 remains queued with no steps.

QSR #145 exact 2eea75b4f40faf3c95e7d3e8484525e51a845f25 / 35920385591 acquired hosted runners on 2026-09-24 01:40–01:54Z: hosted negative completed GREEN; verify reached rustfmt; coverage executed the intended foreign-member destructive-cleanup RED. Positive SELinux job 107382539902 remains queued with no steps.

So the current evidence no longer supports a repository-wide hosted admission outage. Narrow the live queue-health fault to the dedicated positive-LSM self-hosted selector/runner path unless a fresh hosted specimen regresses. Do not transfer earlier runner_id=0/steps=[] hosted observations forward after these executions, and do not weaken the SELinux labels or substitute hosted negative evidence for positive-LSM acceptance.

Fresh current-head pre-execution failure specimen — ContextualWisdomLab/cwl-telemetry#1.

exact head: 78731bc1e68e669a6be2daedd8e9eeed906e1037;
PR state: open Draft, mechanically mergeable, current (not obsolete);
workflow: Telemetry contract run 37887960040, terminal failure;
job: contract 113682110266, terminal failure, with steps=null and logs_url=null;
source classification: documentation-only forward commit adding continuation/architecture/security-operability authorities; no runtime, dependency, workflow, runner label, timeout, or test change;
predecessor control: implementation head 782445aadd6bb2ef3efe7bd688785d1fdb0588f5 previously completed the Telemetry contract, Security Scan, SAST Semgrep, and CodeQL PR gates successfully.

The immediately preceding documentation head d5e3b5d7e9419b156b6cacbf0cccb75d61b0b9c3 exhibited the same pre-step terminal failure in run 37066748682 (initial job 111036418894; failed-jobs rerun 111036783795). Current evidence therefore does not identify a product regression or justify leaf source churn, timeout inflation, selector weakening, another blind rerun, status transfer, or merge bypass. Preserve the exact head until runner/admission owner evidence changes; cwl-telemetry#1 records this run as non-passing infrastructure evidence.

appguardrail PR #1423 exact-head admission evidence (2026-10-09):

head 5150cd79be921550e838b08bbec560052379e797, tree 1369cf3670283dab819d0757843b82ff3f463eb7
terminal failed runs: 37889115839, 37889115704, 37889115651, 37889115665, 37889115649, 37889115682
exact jobs: 113685778603, 113685778788, 113685777365, 113685777574, 113685777262, 113685777224, 113685777362, 113685777755
all 8 jobs: completed/failure, steps=null, logs_url=null

이는 실행된 source/test/security verdict가 아닙니다. 이 exact 응답만으로 billing 원인을 단정하지 않으며, payer/operator admission 원인이 변경된 뒤 unchanged head로 실행 가능한 receipt를 얻어야 합니다. Blind rerun, leaf workaround, gate weakening은 수행하지 않았습니다. PR RCA: ContextualWisdomLab/appguardrail#1423 (comment)

2026-10-09 — mcp-shared-gateway#28 pre-job specimen

Repository/PR: ContextualWisdomLab/mcp-shared-gateway#28
Exact current head: 00428c274e34c21afcccd9c92ca3b4b1d93c1b84
Base: main@18ac89f065d7b022282adec64c3374196c53556d
Run: 37893560304
Terminal: startup_failure; workflow name empty; jobs []
Therefore no runner labels/identity, checkout, or executed steps exist.
Current source delta from previously hosted-GREEN e754f0b0…: RED symlink/oversize credential contract, one-descriptor bounded credential admission, CHANGELOG, and exact-head Gap correction.
Focused local boundary result: valid owner-only input accepted; final symlink and >64 KiB input rejected.
Classification: current-head pre-job workflow compilation/admission failure, not a credential-loader test conclusion.

Two preceding forward heads reproduced the same zero-job class (37893321887, 37893529326). No blind rerun, no-op wake commit, selector weakening, predecessor-status transfer, synthetic success, bypass, merge, or Close was used. PR remains Ready only for review admission and is unmerged pending current-head hosted checks plus qualifying approval.

Exact-head runner/admission evidence for ContextualWisdomLab/appguardrail#1260 after the canonical dashboard severity-boundary repair:

exact head: 98ed23c85b061f2e8068f9523ac160a86ec0c94d
exact tree: 09f05ab0e8d80e5c455e44de5b58f6474301b7a4
Tests 37897298824: jobs 113711461135, 113711461315
Retention Audit Coverage 37897296026: job 113711451393
Security Process 37897296048: jobs 113711451038, 113711451133
Pinned HTTPS Coverage 37897296118: job 113711451614
OpenSSF Evidence Coverage 37897296009: job 113711450637
Scan path context coverage 37897296038: job 113711450754

All six runs are terminal FAILURE, but all eight jobs expose steps=null and logs_url=null. No checkout, test, scanner, or security step executed, so this is not a source verdict. Local exact-tree evidence is 29/29 dashboard-focused and 1,095/1,095 full-suite GREEN. PR #1260 was moved back to Draft; no blind rerun, wake commit, gate weakening, or merge was used.

Exact-head runner/admission evidence for ContextualWisdomLab/appguardrail#999 Gap G-35 update:

exact head: 91130792220e0efcfd9252b709d685f560d7d749
exact tree: cd243afe8b77d502888cbc615ce0650613b1b379
baseline blob: 8f6e056525d2e2757c945e12fee436698d771c8b
Security Process 37897576152: jobs 113712341394, 113712341806
Pinned HTTPS Coverage 37897576231: job 113712341336
Scan path context coverage 37897576156: job 113712341102
Retention Audit Coverage 37897576149: job 113712341450
OpenSSF Evidence Coverage 37897576181: job 113712341334
Tests 37897576151: jobs 113712341162, 113712341381

All jobs are terminal FAILURE with steps=null and logs_url=null; no checkout, baseline test, or security step executed. Local exact-tree baseline integrity is 2/2 GREEN with UTF-8/NUL/replacement/singleton checks and clean diff. PR #999 remains Draft; no blind rerun, wake commit, gate weakening, or merge was used.

appguardrail PR #1424 exact-head hosted-step RCA update (2026-10-09)

Exact head 4ddc75bbe25c024fd2b76be91d08163747906e96, tree ca4966e2dbe10b8f8fb74b650053299c71098cb4.

All pull-request runs reached terminal failure before exposing any job steps or downloadable job logs:

Pinned HTTPS Coverage 37898609104 / job 113715653238
Scan path context coverage 37898609109 / job 113715653329
Retention Audit Coverage 37898609137 / job 113715653880
Security Process 37898609120 / jobs 113715653261, 113715653390
Tests 37898609135 / jobs 113715652833, 113715653148
OpenSSF Evidence Coverage 37898609071 / job 113715653064

For every job the connector reports status=completed, conclusion=failure, steps=null, and logs_url=null. This is the same pre-step organization runner/control-plane failure family; it is not evidence of a source/test failure. Local exact-tree evidence is 1,123 passed plus compileall/diff-check pass. PR #1424 remains Draft and no required check is weakened or bypassed.

appguardrail PR #999 exact-head hosted-step update (2026-10-09)

Exact head fb8ded8a70082cb053ca4c3bc489add2397ff63b, tree 42542d334e04637444b7915851ea736f909b906f.

Scan path context coverage run 37898865040 terminated failure before exposing any step; job 113716474098 reports steps=null and logs_url=null. OpenSSF 37898864916, Security Process 37898864812, Tests 37898864885, Pinned HTTPS 37898864902, and Retention 37898864952 remain queued and are treated as non-blocking waits, not failures or success evidence.

The exact baseline tree passes its focused integrity suite 2/2 and diff check. #999 remains Draft; no blind rerun, approval transfer, or gate bypass is used.

appguardrail PR #999 exact-head terminal hosted-step RCA (2026-10-09)

Exact head fb8ded8a70082cb053ca4c3bc489add2397ff63b, tree 42542d334e04637444b7915851ea736f909b906f.

All six workflows are terminal failure before any job exposed steps or logs:

Scan path 37898865040 / job 113716474098
Tests 37898864885 / jobs 113716473411, 113716473661
Retention 37898864952 / job 113716474287
OpenSSF 37898864916 / job 113716473811
Pinned HTTPS 37898864902 / job 113716473671
Security Process 37898864812 / jobs 113716472830, 113716473246

Every job reports status=completed, conclusion=failure, steps=null, and logs_url=null. No source/test/security command executed. Fresh local exact-tree evidence is baseline integrity 2/2 plus clean diff; this hosted state is runner/control-plane evidence, not a code verdict. #999 remains Draft and no blind rerun or gate bypass is used.

appguardrail PR #1424 exact-head hosted failure evidence

repository: ContextualWisdomLab/appguardrail
PR: feat(security): detect GitHub Actions execution integrity risks appguardrail#1424
exact head: 96fb137b2ae4d81058e81f8fa6ae302a5b20c9ce
exact tree: cf98f891634b767b43f06b5f7a977b75ca9c2246
observed 2026-10-09

All six materialized pull-request workflow runs failed before any executable step evidence was exposed:

Scan path context coverage: run 37900798890, job 113722638827
OpenSSF Evidence Coverage: run 37900798826, job 113722638910
Pinned HTTPS Coverage: run 37900798828, job 113722638792
Tests: run 37900799070, jobs 113722639750 (Python 3.11) and 113722640224 (Python 3.13)
Retention Audit Coverage: run 37900798718, job 113722638723
Security Process: run 37900798811, jobs 113722638770 (appguardrail-scan) and 113722639069 (trivy-fs)

Every job is terminal failure with steps: null and logs_url: null. This reproduces the central pre-step Actions/runtime failure signature rather than a repository test assertion. Local exact-tree verification is 1,138/1,138 full and 67/67 focused, but does not replace hosted exact-head evidence. PR remains Draft; no gate suppression or bypass was applied.

appguardrail PR #1424 third repair exact-head hosted failure evidence

PR: feat(security): detect GitHub Actions execution integrity risks appguardrail#1424
exact head: 0d45c3b16335483de2e0348b4a5f88ed1843324c
exact tree: 837ee553d751163539fb9b4c24072efa73e110e6
observed 2026-10-09

All six exact-head pull-request workflows are terminal pre-step failures:

Pinned HTTPS Coverage: run 37901647894, job 113725349618
Security Process: run 37901647964, jobs 113725350140 and 113725350447
Scan path context coverage: run 37901647976, job 113725349876
OpenSSF Evidence Coverage: run 37901648134, job 113725350487
Tests: run 37901648073, jobs 113725350425 and 113725350594
Retention Audit Coverage: run 37901647909, job 113725350027

Every job reports status=completed, conclusion=failure, steps=null, and logs_url=null. This remains the central Actions admission/runtime signature, not an executed repository assertion. The byte-identical local tree passes 1,151/1,151 full and 80/80 focused tests; that evidence does not replace hosted exact-head execution. PR remains Draft; no rerun loop, gate suppression, or bypass was used.

appguardrail PR #1424 fourth repair exact-head hosted failure evidence

exact head: 7066131672b78dc81cdd3d61e5eaeccf60edc5f4
exact tree: 5d833a8858b9332b7608d0a0ad1d553622ba8e1a
PR: feat(security): detect GitHub Actions execution integrity risks appguardrail#1424
observed 2026-10-09

All six exact-head runs are terminal pre-step failures:

Security Process 37902370029: jobs 113727663392, 113727663480
Scan path 37902370137: job 113727664158
OpenSSF 37902369964: job 113727663428
Pinned HTTPS 37902370175: job 113727664083
Tests 37902370141: jobs 113727664114, 113727664576
Retention 37902370012: job 113727663678

All eight jobs report steps=null and logs_url=null. No source/test/security command materialized; this is the same central Actions admission/runtime signature. The byte-identical local tree passes 1,160/1,160 full and 89/89 focused tests, but that does not replace exact-head hosted execution. PR remains Draft and no gate was suppressed or bypassed.

appguardrail PR #1424 exact-head hosted-check RCA update

Exact head a850c1a694d584a95d122b8c2c04ed16445ece9c, exact tested tree 83c90da2382f7026951549008abd4d9b4b8f48b5 passed 1,170/1,170 local tests, 99/99 focused GitHub Actions tests, compileall, and diff checks. All five uploaded blobs match the tested local Git object hashes.

All six hosted workflows failed before a runnable step/log record materialized: runs 37903426442, 37903426405, 37903426571, 37903426592, 37903426630, 37903426387; eight jobs total, each steps=null and logs_url=null. This repeats the central pre-step Actions/runtime failure class rather than exposing a repository test assertion or detector failure. appguardrail #1424 remains Draft and merge-held pending real exact-head hosted execution and qualifying review; no retry can be justified from missing logs, and no gate was weakened.

appguardrail #1424 final exact-head Actions RCA: head a47de52c1f6d0f49e44a72e35b713b1738bf10fa, tree d73233defc3a386f5e64a2327da75f501f7e1f82, local 1,187/1,187 full and 116/116 focused GREEN. Hosted runs 37904591588, 37904591464, 37904591492, 37904591580, 37904591490, 37904591592 again terminate before step/log materialization; all eight jobs report steps=null, logs_url=null. This remains central Actions/runtime evidence, not a source-test verdict. PR stays Draft and merge-held; no suppression or gate weakening.

appguardrail baseline #999 exact-head RCA: head 27a8e68ae5d595a1444f58763207ad8e52268e83, tree ea1209dbea3210ad0664c2278a67f5f22f909915, baseline integrity 2/2 GREEN. Hosted runs 37904803692, 37904803434, 37904803373, 37904803534, 37904803454, 37904803406 contain eight terminal jobs, all steps=null and logs_url=null. This is the same central pre-step Actions/runtime failure class. #999 remains Draft/merge-held; no gate change.

Fresh continuation specimen — learning-interoperability-contracts (2026-10-09)

Three current exact heads independently reproduced terminal pre-step failure on the same repository-local ubuntu-24.04 Quality workflow after real source changes:

root PR Add Palette journal for profile repo #1 f0b475aecd327c213e74415f8f70630b7ddc9611: run 37904955025, job 113736075751;
CEFR child PR chore: Record lack of UI codebase in palette journal #5 8d7bd65df0fdee4dcce56d789283f1ff42ce8f92: run 37905004822, job 113736243024;
xAPI child PR Block OpenCode approval on stale fact evidence #7 dce2c9d679fa8f20b3371ee95b5cd1e86ca24ac5: run 37905004944, job 113736242458.

Each job is terminal failure with steps=null and no job log URL; direct log retrieval returns HTTP 404 BlobNotFound. Thus no checkout or repository test step executed. Local exact-tree validation is independently GREEN for the canonical Python contract, TypeScript consumer, CEFR 13/13 or xAPI 4/4 regressions as applicable, and diff checks; Rust was not claimed locally because the available environment lacks rustc.

All three PRs remain Draft/open/mergeable. No no-op wake, rerun, selector weakening, timeout inflation, bypass, predecessor-status transfer or merge was performed. Preserve these exact specimens as current-head admission evidence; they do not prove a single platform cause, but they rule out an executed source-test failure for these runs.

Navigation Menu

Repository navigation

ops: continue queue-health evidence after #712 comment-cap exhaustion #2356

Why this successor exists

Fresh continuation specimen — quarantine-sandbox-runtime

Continuation rules

Completion

280 remaining items

2026-10-09 — mcp-shared-gateway#28 pre-job specimen

Fresh continuation specimen — learning-interoperability-contracts (2026-10-09)

Metadata

Assignees

Labels

Type

Projects

Milestone

Relationships

Development

ops: continue queue-health evidence after #712 comment-cap exhaustion #2356

Description

Why this successor exists

Fresh continuation specimen — quarantine-sandbox-runtime

Continuation rules

Completion

Activity

seonghobae commented on Sep 23, 2026

seonghobae commented on Sep 23, 2026

seonghobae commented on Sep 23, 2026

seonghobae commented on Sep 23, 2026

seonghobae commented on Sep 24, 2026

seonghobae commented on Sep 24, 2026

seonghobae commented on Sep 24, 2026

seonghobae commented on Sep 24, 2026

seonghobae commented on Sep 24, 2026

280 remaining items

seonghobae commented on Oct 9, 2026

seonghobae commented on Oct 9, 2026

seonghobae commented on Oct 9, 2026

2026-10-09 — mcp-shared-gateway#28 pre-job specimen

seonghobae commented on Oct 9, 2026

seonghobae commented on Oct 9, 2026

seonghobae commented on Oct 9, 2026

seonghobae commented on Oct 9, 2026

seonghobae commented on Oct 9, 2026

seonghobae commented on Oct 9, 2026

seonghobae commented on Oct 9, 2026

seonghobae commented on Oct 9, 2026

seonghobae commented on Oct 9, 2026

seonghobae commented on Oct 9, 2026

seonghobae commented on Oct 9, 2026

seonghobae commented on Oct 9, 2026

Fresh continuation specimen — learning-interoperability-contracts (2026-10-09)

Metadata

Metadata

Assignees

Labels

Type

Projects

Milestone

Relationships

Development

Issue actions